Our Valued Sponsor
OpinionsConsumer ReviewsGuides and How TosCoffeeGeek ReviewsResourcesForums
opinions and articles
Coffee in Australia by Alan Frew
Domestic Espresso Machine Roundup
Posted: July 1, 2002
Article rating: 8.8
feedback: (8) comments | read | write
Shots on a Silvia

I've received several queries in the last month asking me about the various domestic espresso machines now appearing in major department stores. Brands mentioned have been Sunbeam, DeLonghi, Breville, Krups and recently Gaggia. The Gaggia company is now wholly owned by Saeco, as is CMS, the Australian Saeco distributor, which has become Saeco Australia P/L.

All this corporate mixing will probably mean big changes in the product lines and distribution arrangements, and the first of these are appearing. The Gaggia agency has been moved after many years at Coffee Mio and is now distributed by the former Krups agent ex Sydney, thus its appearance in the big stores.

Anyway, when I looked at the machines there were so many different models to choose from that a thorough evaluation seemed impossible. Then I realised that I didn't really need to look at specific machines so much as the way they are put together. So this article concentrates on the components rather then the brand or model.

Ulka Pump
The stock ULKA pump found in so many machines.

To begin with, the pump. 18 Bar, 15 Bar, 9 Bar...what's the difference? In reality, none. ALL the pumps used in domestic machines are vibration pumps, usually made by either Eaton or ULKA, and all of them are basically identical. As long as the machine has a pump, you can ignore the "Bar" ratings.

Then comes the heating technology, and it's here where fundamental differences which profoundly affect espresso production occur.

Thermoblock Inside Thermoblock
An aluminium thermoblock with exterior element.
Inside the block. "A maze of twisty channels, all alike."

"Thermoblock" technology means that the water is heated in a multi channel metal block with an exterior element. The total volume of water inside the block at any given time is small, no more than 10ml, and the theory is that heating the block via an external element and pushing the water through at a set flow rate will produce the correct water temperature. In practice the first water touching the coffee is too hot and the rest usually too cool. In addition the flow restriction reduces the pressure at the group, making normal extraction difficult, so ALL thermoblock machines use "crema enhancing" devices of various types.

SS Boiler Inside SS Boiler
A 900w stainless steel boiler as used by Krups, Saeco etc.
An inside view of a 900W stainless steel boiler

Steaming is accomplished by using the pump to pulse small bursts of water into the overheated block, which is then supposed to flash into steam. Again in practice steam production tends to be feeble and "wet".

Thermoblock machines will produce average espresso and reasonable milk drinks given good technique, but anyone who wants better than average should avoid them.

2 Boilers
The standard S/S boiler on the left, and the Silvia boiler on the right. Big, isn't it?

Boiler machines tend to fall into 3 categories:

  • Gaggia, which have a proprietary aluminium boiler with 2 external heating elements and a boiler volume of 120ml;
  • Stainless steel with copper element, boiler volume 180ml;
  • Marine brass with copper element, boiler volume 300ml.

All 3 boiler types have sufficient water volume to keep reasonable temperature stability throughout a double shot. When heated to steam temperature, the limited volumes of the smaller boilers can mean slightly less steam time and power, but all have enough for average use. In my experience the larger volume boilers have a faster "recovery time" between shots and that bit of extra steam, so that you can produce 6 cappuccinos in 5 minutes for your dinner party.

Again in my experience the Gaggia boilers tend to corrode internally. They are attached to a brass group, and the combination of dissimilar metals and hot electrically conductive water simply eats the aluminium. This can also happen with aluminium thermoblocks, which is why some of the more upmarket ones are now lined with stainless steel.

Inside Gaggia Gaggia Closeup
Inside an 18 month old Gaggia boiler. The aluminium top has corroded, the chromed brass base is in perfect condition.
This close-up shows the extent to which the metal has been eaten away.

Finally, the larger brass boilers tend to have higher power elements than the smaller stainless steel ones, again giving better thermal stability and faster recovery.

Thermoblock (10ml)Aluminium Boiler (120ml)Stainless Boiler (180ml)Brass Boiler (300ml)
Sunbeam Cafe Series
DeLonghi
Breville (Dualit)
Krups 2000 & 4000 Series
Gaggia (all local models.)Saeco Via Venezia
La Pavoni
Spidem
Krups Vivo/Gusto
Quaha Junior & Napoletana
Rancilio Audrey, Silvia, Lucy
Solis SL70 & SL90

The GROUP is the bit of the machine that the portafilter locks in to, where the water is pumped through a "showerscreen" on to the coffee. All of the thermoblock machines I've seen have aluminium groups with stainless steel shower screens. The smaller stainless steel boiler machines also have aluminium exterior groups and S/S screens. Gaggias have a brass group with a S/S screen, brass boiler machines have brass groups with S/S screens. Of all domestic machines, only the Rancilio Silvia has a commercial brass group and S/S screen setup.

Silvia Group Portafilters
The "Commercial" group as found on the Rancilio Silvia.
The "Commercial" Rancilio 58mm portafilter is on the right, the 57mm Quaha is on the left.

Portafilters are another point of differentiation, with (again) thermoblock machines tending to have cheap aluminium portafilters and quality boiler machines chromed brass portafilters. All this concentration on metal types may seem a bit strange, but excellent espresso production relies on thermal stability of all the components in the process. Copper and brass are best, which is why you find them in commercial machines.

Both Gaggia and Rancilio use commercial portafilters and baskets on their domestic machines. Solis and Quaha have brass portafilters but non-commercial filter baskets. Saeco uses its patented pressurized portafilter, made mostly of plastic but with some brass, as does Krups on its higher end machines. The Saeco portafilter pops up on other brands of machines such as La Pavoni and Spidem, so it's a good bet that these brands are "rebadges", Saeco inside another manufacturer's body design.

All the rest (as far as I could tell) are aluminium, lightweight and cheap.

Solenoid "3-way" valves are only available on high end machines, they relieve pressure in the portafilter immediately after brewing so you can pull consecutive shots.

Recommendations

Now we get down to the hard part, what do I recommend and why?

Click for larger image Click for larger image Click for larger image
The Krups Vivo (Gusto) 880. A$230.
Gaggia Carezza, same insides and portafilter as the "Coffee", A$330.
Gaggia Classic, as for the Carezza, but S/S body and 3 way solenoid. A$599.

Well, from the cheapest to the most expensive, here they are. Krups Vivo K880, (also called the Gusto in North America) approx. A$230.00 (US$119), has a pump, stainless steel boiler, cheap portafilter but with good technique you can make a decent espresso.

Gaggia Carreza, A$330.00 (US$189), a modern Gaggia Coffee at half the original price. I can't believe that they're suddenly so cheap, but it appears Saeco is determined to establish them as a mass market brand. Simply kills ALL the thermoblock opposition anywhere near the price, as well as any other non-solenoid machine. Buy this in preference to Sunbeam, Saeco, Breville (Dualit elsewhere) DeLonghi, Krups Novo et al.

Gaggia Classic A$599.00 (US$379). $200.00 cheaper than it was a couple of months ago, commercial group, 3-way valve, S/S body.

Click for larger image Click for larger image Click for larger image
Quaha Junior II, 100% S/S body, brass boiler, 3 way solenoid. A$495.
Quaha Napoletana II, S/S body, brass boiler, 3 way solenoid and grinder, A$682
Rancilio Silvia, one with the lot! A$748.

Quaha Junior II, A$495.00, S/S body, 3-way valve, but non-commercial portafilter and group. Produces identical espresso to the Classic but A$100.00 cheaper and longer boiler life.

Quaha Napoletana II, A$682.00, as for the Junior but includes built in Lux (a.k.a. Isomac, Innova Conical etc.) grinder. Best "value for money" kit I know of. NOT available in the USA, so please don't ask me!

Rancilio Silvia, A$748.00 (US$395). In my opinion the only home espresso machine that can consistently produce "commercial" quality espresso or better, limited only by operator technique. S/S body, fully commercial group, water distribution and portafilter system, 3-way valve.

Click for larger image
All I want for Christmas is... a Tea! A$2000.

The step up from the Silvia is a tall one, around A$2,000 for a Pasquini Livia, Isomac TEA or ECM Giotto. These machines are really single group commercial machines with a tank and vibratory pump setup, instead of being plumbed in with a rotary pump. Boilers are usually around a litre or more, which is a lot of water to heat up if you only make a couple of espressos a day.

Article rating: 8.8
Posted: July 1, 2002
feedback: (8) comments | read | write
All Retired Columnists Articles
These articles are listed in alphabetical order, first by columnist, then by article title.
A day in the life
Alan Frew, 04.24.2002, Rated: 7.4
A Dinner Party Challenge
Alan Frew, 10.15.2002, Rated: 7.8
Celebrate The Bean
Alan Frew, 03.29.2003, Rated: 8.1
Domestic Espresso Repair
Alan Frew, 05.20.2002, Rated: 9.1
Domestic Grinder Analysis
Alan Frew, 08.30.2002, Rated: 8.5
Domestic Machine Reviews
Alan Frew, 08.22.2003, Rated: 8.2
Espresso Blend Building
Alan Frew, 03.25.2002, Rated: 7.7
Imex Roaster Revisited
Alan Frew, 12.15.2001, Rated: 7.5
Meditations on a Mantra
Alan Frew, 09.28.2002, Rated: 8.3
My View of SCAA 2002
Alan Frew, 06.10.2002, Rated: 8.2
Plenty Questions
Alan Frew, 01.22.2002, Rated: 8.4
Price Up, Taste Down
Alan Frew, 01.07.2002, Rated: 8.2
Show Me The Money!
Alan Frew, 12.28.2001, Rated: 8.4
Small Espresso Tweaks
Alan Frew, 02.14.2003, Rated: 8.5
Suck It And See
Alan Frew, 08.09.2002, Rated: 8.1
The Coffee Academy
Alan Frew, 07.21.2003, Rated: 7.7
The Top 10 Coffee Myths
Alan Frew, 07.15.2002, Rated: 8.1
Turn on, Tune in, Espresso out
Alan Frew, 02.23.2002, Rated: 8.3
Up at the Sharp End
Alan Frew, 05.24.2003, Rated: 7.5
Andrea Illy Speaks in New York
Liz Clayton, 01.15.2008, Rated: 8.3
NYC Cafe Scene Report: March 2008
Liz Clayton, 03.28.2008, Rated: 8.7
Humble Beginnings
Aaron De Lazzer, 01.25.2002, Rated: 7.5
Latte "Tips", Part Two
Aaron De Lazzer, 12.28.2001, Rated: 8.0
Latte Art, some "Tips"
Aaron De Lazzer, 12.10.2001, Rated: 7.6
Love and Hate in Espresso
Aaron De Lazzer, 07.26.2003, Rated: 8.1
Mediocre Coffee
Aaron De Lazzer, 07.13.2003, Rated: 7.9
Ristretto Shots
Aaron De Lazzer, 02.24.2002, Rated: 7.9
Training Espresso
Aaron De Lazzer, 06.28.2003, Rated: 8.4
An Introduction
Jason Dominy, 04.28.2012, Rated: 8.6
Making Progress
Ed Gabrielle, 09.15.2002, Rated: 8.5
Meeting Silvia
Ed Gabrielle, 07.21.2002, Rated: 6.9
Ethiopian Sidamos
Karen Hamilton, 10.15.2008, Rated: 8.8
Ritual Coffee
Karen Hamilton, 11.15.2008, Rated: 8.6
Coffee Business Journey
Jack Hanna, 04.08.2012, Rated: 8.3
Coffee and a Donut
James Hoffmann, 06.02.2007, Rated: 7.0
Crema
James Hoffmann, 10.14.2006, Rated: 8.9
Bean There Part 4
Terry Montague, 05.26.2002, Rated: 8.6
Bean There, Roasted That Pt.3
Terry Montague, 01.28.2002, Rated: 8.5
Beans & Roasts, Pt.2
Terry Montague, 01.13.2002, Rated: 9.0
Beans and Roasts, Pt.1
Terry Montague, 12.31.2001, Rated: 8.3
Good taste - Good cause
Terry Montague, 04.29.2002, Rated: 8.8
Notes from the Road
Lou Pescarmona, 08.16.2002, Rated: 8.3
Reluctant Admission
Lou Pescarmona, 05.12.2002, Rated: 8.3
Supreme Bean
Lou Pescarmona, 06.16.2002, Rated: 8.2
Cold Espresso
Jim Piccinich, 10.23.2002, Rated: 8.3
Power Protection
Jim Piccinich, 03.01.2003, Rated: 6.3
So Many Choices
Jim Piccinich, 09.15.2002, Rated: 8.4
Temp Regulation 101
Jim Piccinich, 07.04.2003, Rated: 8.1
What is a Heat Exchanger?
Jim Piccinich, 07.14.2003, Rated: 7.7
Faema E61 Part 2
Paul Pratt, 12.18.2007, Rated: 8.8
Faema E61 Restoration
Paul Pratt, 06.05.2007, Rated: 8.8
Setting the Scene
Paul Pratt, 11.15.2003, Rated: 6.7
Barista Basics, or Not
George Sabados, 05.03.2004, Rated: 7.8
Cafe Culture Downunder
George Sabados, 06.12.2007, Rated: 7.8
Changing Cafe Owner Thinking
George Sabados, 02.06.2006, Rated: 7.6
The End of the Barista
George Sabados, 12.27.2006, Rated: 7.8
"Espresso", a review.
Ted Simpson, 01.20.2002, Rated: 8.2
A Quick Introduction
Ted Simpson, 12.14.2001, Rated: 8.5
The Hunt
Ted Simpson, 12.28.2001, Rated: 8.6
Grinder Adjustments
Chris Weaver, 03.01.2012, Rated: 8.1
     
Interactive
Search
Login Password
forgot pw | signup
quickNav
advertisement
sponsorad
Support Coffee Kids
Coffee Kids is a non profit charity working with farming communities around the world. Donate today!
www.coffeekids.org
sponsorad
Learn @seattlecoffeegear
Learn all about coffee, watch videos, read how-to articles.
www.seattlecoffeegear.com
sponsorad
Don't suffer bad espresso
Package deals on the best machines from Izzo, Quick Mill, VBM, La Marzocco & more.
www.clivecoffee.com
Home | Opinions | Consumer Reviews | Guides & How Tos | CoffeeGeek Reviews | Resources | Forums | Contact Us
CoffeeGeek.com, CoffeeGeek, and Coffee Geek, along with all associated content & images are copyright ©2000-2014 by Mark Prince, all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated. Content, code, and images may not be reused without permission. Usage of this website signifies agreement with our Terms and Conditions. (0.430850028992)
Privacy Policy | Copyright Info | Terms and Conditions | CoffeeGeek Advertisers | RSS | Find us on Google+