Our Valued Sponsor
OpinionsConsumer ReviewsGuides and How TosCoffeeGeek ReviewsResourcesForums
opinions and articles
The Cafe Stage
The 3x Basket & The Elusive God Shot
Posted: July 16, 2002
Article rating: 7.3
feedback: (16) comments | read | write
Triple Basket, with double and single behind it.

The idea of a god shot invokes feelings of both mystery and artistry.  It would appear to be the ultimate achievement in the world of espresso.  What is a god shot?  Thatís a fair question. On the mystical side, it is the alchemistís coffee.  On the artistic level, it is a coming of age, indicating that one has finally gotten the feel for what espresso is all about. But one personís god shot maybe anotherís dreck. No matter what the physical parameters are as well as the technical difficulties, it always comes down to what is sitting in the cup.  Timing numbers and the volume of the shot are an attempt to give guidelines within which satisfactory espresso can be executed. No matter how technically perfect the espresso is, if it doesnít taste good, it is not a god shot.

What are some of the physical characteristics of a god shot?  Heavy crema, a luxurious mouth feel of density, an over the top concentration that simply has to be experienced, great balance in which bitterness is present but does not dominate, a mouth assaulting bitter sweetness, layered depth and complexity, a long after taste, and great pleasure. It will be a restricted pour or ristretto in which the shot is terminated by sight just as the stream begins to lighten. There arenít going to be any 3 oz god shots! Volume-wise it is going to be closer to 3/4 oz, not 2 ounces. The heavy duty espresso cups with the La Marzocco logo only hold about 50 ml and that is by design. A god shot will not even come close to filling that cup Ė and not even half way.

Still, the god shot is highly subjective and relative to oneís own espresso experiences.  Note: Andrea Illyís Espresso Coffee: the Chemistry of Quality has color photographs of espresso.  Those are not god shots!  What is pictured there is the minimal standard for acceptable quality commercial espresso. With adequate equipment and satisfactory technique, it is not that difficult to meet that standard. A god shot, though, is a very different animal. It pushes oneís hardware to its limits and then requires meticulous technique. The vast majority of todayís home espresso equipment does not possess sufficient horsepower to pull it off.

Aside from near commercial grade equipment or better, one also needs a 3X basket. In this version of a god shot, the 3X basket is an absolute necessity. The rationale is very simple: a 3X basket will hold about 50% more grind by weight, compared to a 2X basket. The timing numbers for a 2X or 3X basket are very similar with the result being significantly more extraction from the puck in the same amount of time. The result with a 3X basket is a very dense, concentrated shot that is at least twice as concentrated as a 2X basket, if not more.

The three baskets designed for the Livia's portafilter. From the left, the single, the double, and the triple basket.

My own hardware consists of: a Pasquini Livia 90, Pasquini Moka 90 grinder, a digital scale with a tare function, a bathroom scale, three Reg Barber stainless steel tampers, a 3X basket from Pasquini, and an extra portafilter with a blind filter to backflush between shots. My espresso blend of choice is Josuma's Malabar Gold.

The technical details with rationale have been well delineated in David Schomer's: Espresso Coffee: Professional Techniques. The Schomer and Illy books are absolute necessities for those who are seriously interested in espresso.

Click for larger image
Pack from a double basket, 17 grams. Click to enlarge.
Click for larger image
Pack from triple basket, 24 grams. Click to enlarge.

I am not going to repeat David Schomer's technique list, but would suggest that those, who are serious, buy his book and read it. Schomer's techniques have to do with a 2X basket and do not totally transfer into a 3X basket. The difference is that the same methods of dosing, packing, and tamping do not work in a 3X basket. There simply is not enough grind in the basket - hence the need for a digital scale and altered tamping technique. If a 2X basket can hold 16 or 17 grams, then the 3X basket should hold 24 grams, plus or minus a gram and still have the PF/basket assembly easily locked into place.

The alteration to Schomer's techniques are to use the plastic tamper built into the Moka 90 grinder (a tamper that requires an upward force on the portafilter) to compact the grind and create enough space so that about 24 grams can be held in the 3X basket. The exact amount of grind will depend upon the timing numbers that are generated with the pulled shot or pour. Once there is 24 grams or so in the 3X basket, one will immediately notice the unevenness of the puck with visible air spaces. Use the up tamper to level the puck as best as one can.

The first real tamp is with a 58 mm diameter flat bottomed, stainless steel Reg Barber tamper that is bottom weighted. This is a quick leveling tamp. The force of this tamp is in the range of 13 to 20 kg (28-45lbs). Rock the 58 mm tamper around the inner circumference of the puck. When finished, the puck should be near level.

The second tamp is with a 52 mm diameter flat bottomed, stainless steel Reg Barber. Start anywhere on the inner circumference of the puck and then serially tamp the entire circumference in incremental, overlapping steps. Do this at least two times around the inner circumference, if not three times. Force: 25 to 30 kg of pressure (55-66lbs). Check levelness of puck and make adjustments as necessary.

Click for larger image
A triple basket prepared in the manner described in this article. Click to enlarge.
Click for larger image
A double pack, using normal methods of grind, dose, level, tamp, knock, tamp and polish. Click to enlarge.

The third tamp is with a 58 mm flat bottomed tamper at a force slightly greater than 30 kg (+65lbs). The fourth tamp is with a 58 mm convex tamper at more than 35kg of force (77lbs). I do not think that there is any qualitative difference between a flat or convex 58 mm tamper and if I had to choose one, I would pick the flat bottomed one. In other words, the fourth tamp includes the final tamp and polish and the entire tamping process can be done with two tampers. No tapping on the PF/basket assembly is needed during this tamping process.

I think that it is crucial to use a smaller diameter tamper for the intermediate pack in order to eliminate air spaces and avoid channeling. This packing and tamping procedure results in a very dense puck that will test the capabilities of both the grinder and the espresso machine. If the pack is uneven, one will see channeling in the stream and perhaps pitting on the surface of the puck. One way of checking for the evenness of the tamp is to use a double spouted portafilter. Ideally, the two streams of espresso should be the same from both spouts.

My own preferred timing numbers for the pour with the Pasquini equipment is a total time between 18 to 22 seconds. Time is begun when the switch is activated to begin the espresso pour and terminated when the switch is flipped off. One has to look at the color of the pour and how it hangs to determine when to terminate the shot. The time from the flip of the switch until espresso appears at the spout is what I term pre-infusion (PI). My preferred window is a PI time from 7 to 9 seconds. Other equipment may have slightly different timing numbers.

Click for larger image
The double and triple packs, compared. Ed.note: the technique Carl describes for prepping the triple pack made this a very solid chunk of coffee; the double pack, prepared the ordinary way, had already broken apart when this photo was taken (obscured by camera angle). Click to enlarge.

The dosing, packing, and tamping require time and practice. One is in a race to maintain as much heat as possible in the PF/basket assembly that is outside of the group. 14kg, or 30 lbs of pressure has been a sacred number with regards to conventional preparation of the espresso pack, and this technique dramatically exceeds it. There is a concern with repetitive stress syndrome. I limit my espresso sessions to six shots because that is what 215 grams (7 oz) of green beans will yield with two roast cycles of 110 grams (3.5oz) each with a Hearthware Home Innovations Precision roaster, the roaster I use regularly. I usually make espresso twice a week on weekends because it is a very time consuming process.

One way to a god shot lies in a 3X basket, near commercial grade hardware or better, and meticulous attention to detail. The journey began with my first and only espresso machine, the Livia 90, purchased at the end of November 2000. Superior espresso is more than simply activating the espresso machine. The learning curve has been steep and littered with many failures, roadblocks, and false successes. That was with a 2X basket. The 3X basket with a potential god shot is more demanding. There is enough variability in the tamping procedure to dramatically affect the shot. The god shot is the Holy Grail of coffee and there is enough detail in this article to achieve it on more than a random basis.

Carl Lau is a charter member of the CoffeeGeek site, and constantly tweaks and refines his espresso prepping technique. This is an ongoing process for him, and he wants to bring this rather controversial view of what constitutes a "god shot" to the CoffeeGeek readers.

Article rating: 7.3
Posted: July 16, 2002
feedback: (16) comments | read | write
The Cafe Stage Column Archives  
Column Description
The Cafe Stage is your chance to get something off your chest. Think of it as a speakers' corner, but in a virtual cafe. As long as the subject even closely relates to coffee, espresso, cafes and coffee culture, it's a potential article we want to put up on the CoffeeGeek site. Visiting authors can also write on subjects near and dear to them.  Rants, raves, reminisces, information, it's all good.

Find out how to submit your story

Coffee, Tea and Geekery
07.24.2012
Starbucks Tries Something New
03.06.2012
Making Coffee in 1918
09.07.2011
Jars of Clay - CoffeeGeeks!
05.12.2009
Trans-Canada Coffee Adventure Part 3
02.02.2008
canada coffee adventure part 2
12.03.2007
Canada Coffee Adventure Part 1
11.19.2007
Argentine Barista
09.21.2007
Coffee in Poland
08.30.2007
The Decaf Drinker
03.26.2007
Exploring Coffee in Dubai
03.22.2007
Espresso Advice
12.21.2006
Coffee Culture Portugal
05.04.2006
Robusta's Rehab
02.01.2006
2 Hours of Joint Solitude
10.19.2005
Coffee and Wine
08.31.2005
CoffeeGeek and You
08.25.2005
Cold Coffee Friendships
10.18.2004
The Latte Gambit
06.02.2003
Cozumel Coffee
02.25.2003
Chocolate Espresso
02.03.2003
Distinct Drinks
01.08.2003
Ethical Coffees
11.22.2002
Big Baskets and God Shots
07.17.2002
Intelligentsia Espresso-In
06.23.2002
Cafe du Monde
03.05.2002
Interactive
Search
Login Password
forgot pw | signup
quickNav
advertisement
sponsorad
Learn @seattlecoffeegear
Learn all about coffee, watch videos, read how-to articles.
www.seattlecoffeegear.com
sponsorad
Home Espresso Machines
Watch videos with Gail & Kat, Rocket, Jura Capresso, Saeco, Rancilio, Quick Mill, Nespresso
www.seattlecoffeegear.com
sponsorad
Rancilio Silvia - How to
Step by step guide for easy brewing and steaming with the Rancilio Silvia
www.seattlecoffeegear.com
Home | Opinions | Consumer Reviews | Guides & How Tos | CoffeeGeek Reviews | Resources | Forums | Contact Us
CoffeeGeek.com, CoffeeGeek, and Coffee Geek, along with all associated content & images are copyright ©2000-2014 by Mark Prince, all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated. Content, code, and images may not be reused without permission. Usage of this website signifies agreement with our Terms and Conditions. (0.291260957718)
Privacy Policy | Copyright Info | Terms and Conditions | CoffeeGeek Advertisers | RSS | Find us on Google+