Our Valued Sponsor
OpinionsConsumer ReviewsGuides and How TosCoffeeGeek ReviewsResourcesForums
consumer product reviews
roasters, accessories & miscellaneous
Hottop Roaster - Sherman Amsel's Review
Posted: April 28, 2006, 10:39am
review rating: 7.6
feedback: (0) comments | read | write
Hottop Coffee Roaster
Where to Buy
Arrow Seattle Coffee Gear
 List your business site here.
About "Where to Buy"

More About This Product
Arrow The Hottop Roaster has 27 Reviews
Arrow The Hottop Roaster has been rated 7.27 overall by our member reviewers
Arrow This product has been in our review database since November 4, 2003.
Arrow Hottop Roaster reviews have been viewed 161,997 times (updated hourly).

Quality Reviews
These are some of the best-written reviews for this product, as judged by our members.
Name Ranking
Sam Decock 9.50
Bruce G 9.00
Aaron Tubbs 8.54
Doug Jamieson 8.50
Darshan-Josiah Barber 8.50

Previous Review Next Review
Ratings and Stats Overall Rating: 9.0
Manufacturer: Chang Yue Quality: 9
Average Price: $550.00 Usability: 9
Price Paid: $685.00 Cost vs. Value 10
Where Bought: sweet maria's Aesthetics 8
Owned for: 1 month Overall 9
Writer's Expertise: I love coffee Would Buy Again: Yes
Similar Items Owned: la cimbali junior dt1 espresso machine, macap m4 grinder
Bottom Line: worthwhile investment for the coffee addict, but be prepared for a learning curve!
Positive Product Points
  • large capacity roasts (good and bad)
  • WELL-WRITTEN instruction manual - this goes a long way towards customer confidence and ease of use
  • external cooling works very well
  • simple to maintain, clean and change filters
Negative Product Points
  • it's very large - the photos do not provide a decent scale.  i was surpised at how much counter space the machine takes up.
  • the various pre-programmed beeps can be annoying, and can't be turned off
  • probably impossible to change the roasting temperature - you can only adjust the time in the roasting chamber
  • unless you take it completely apart and thoroughly clean it after every roast, it keeps smelling like burnt coffee
  • only allows 230 - 270 gram roasts, with 250 grams being optimal.  smaller roast sizes are not supported.
Detailed Commentary

i'm brand new to home roasting.  i decided to take the plunge because my sweetheart couldn't figure out a birthday present, and i figured as long as she's willing to buy one of these, i'm willing to learn.  :-)  sometimes, the best things in life happen by accident!

i have done 5 roasts in the hottop over the last month.  i was able to use 1.5 of them.  i'm definitely on the learning curve, and have spent more time than i care to admit on sweet maria's website (where i purchased the hottop) learning about roast levels.  after burning the first batch all the way to carbon, and then mis-measuring the second batch (which also went to carbon), my third roast was too light.  i stopped the roast at "city", which was a mistake.  it did NOT make drinkable espresso!  the fourth roast was "almost perfect" - needed about 30 seconds more to go from full city to almost viennese.  and, the 5th roast came out just about as i like it - "virtually perfect" - more than full city, just slightly less than viennese.  the programmed time for this roast level was 18:30 with 250g of beans.

now, i feel i have a good baseline from which to deviate and experiment.  i have learned that the hottop (or perhaps coffee roasting in general) is sensitive to the final few seconds of roasting - all the "action" takes place after the First Crack and before the Second Crack ends.  this time interval seems to be about 1 minute or less!  the "almost perfect" roast mentioned above was stopped at 18 minutes exactly; the virually perfect roast was stopped at 18:30.  the final 30 seconds made all the difference between wincing when i tasted the coffee, and truly enjoying a rich, smooth, full bodied espresso with all that deep-roasted flavor.

next roast will be for 18:40, just to see what happens with 10 seconds more time on the roast.  :)

in terms of use, the hottop couldn't be simpler.  you press the Power button to turn it on, then the Time button to set the number of minutes to roast.  it comes up by default with 17 minutes, and each push of the Time button adds another minute.  the Plus button adds seconds to the roast time, and just holding it down makes the seconds count out fairly quickly.  then, one more push of a button - Start - makes the hottop begin.  the unit starts spinning its drum and heating up the roasting chamber.  when it's ready, it'll beep at you for 30 seconds (kind of annoying that it won't stop), and that's when you pour the pre-measured beans in through the top.  a nifty, perfectly shaped funnel is provided that fits right into the little door on top where the coffee beans go.  that's all it takes to get your roast going.

there is a little window on the front of the roasting chamber to watch your beans through.  you can see the color changes, and observe the movement of the beans back and forth as the drum roatates.  after about 15 minutes, the sound of the First Crack is easy to hear, as the roaster is very quiet as it operates.  smoke tends to come from a number of places on the hottop - from the side vents where the heating element is, from the door where you pour in the beans, from the front of the roasting chamber where the front plate attaches, and from the back where a fan drives air and smoke from the roasting chamber through a filter.  you need a good overhead hood to evacuate all the smoke.

after each roast, i clean out the chaff tray.  and, after 4 roasts, per the instruction manual, i take the hottop apart and clean all the components.  it is simple to take apart with just a phillips screwdriver.  also, putting it back together was easy.  but, there was an awful lot of chaff under a metal flap in the roasting chamber that did not make it to the chaff tray.  it was easy to get the chaff out with a chop stick, but i think that's what makes the roaster smell like burnt coffee.  it's too bad you have to disassemble the thing completely to get this chaff - once i removed it, the hottop no longer had that smell.  i'll probably just learn to live with a bit of a burnt coffee aroma in my house.  completely taking the hottop apart after every roast is too much for me.  chaff tray, no problem.  complete and thorough cleaning after each and every roast, no way.  disassembly every 4 or 5 roasts is acceptable.

the hottop does a very good job of cooling the beans after roasting.  when ejected with a push of a button, or when the programmed time elapses, a door on the bottom opens up, and allows the hot beans to fall into a perforated stainless steel pan.  (the hottop beeps in yet another annoying and unstoppable way as it is ejecting the beans.)  air blows up through the perforations, and a small vane spins under the beans to move them around.  these two things work in concert to cool your beans down completely within about 5 minutes.  there is a rather large blast of smoke to evacuate when the hot beans go from the roasting chamber to the cooling pan, so turn your hood  fan on high at this point!  once cooled, the beans can immediately go to a storage container.  i leave the top of the container open for 12 hours after that to allow de-gassing, and then seal it until i use the beans.

once the hottop cools, you must clean the chaff tray, or it will not allow you to roast again.  this seems right, as the chaff could catch fire if allowed to build up.

overall, i am extremely happy with the way the machine works, the quality of the roasts (very even), ease of use and ease of cleaning and maintenace.  and, the freshness of "only days old" roasted coffee beans can't be beat by any store!  (sorry peet's, you just lost a loyal customer!  but i'll be back for the pastries.  :-) )

Buying Experience

i bought the hottop from sweet maria's.  for $10 more, they will send you 5 lbs. of beans.  that's good, as i ruined at least 1 1/2 pounds of beans on the learning curve.  i paid more than the average price listed at the top because i got the brand new digital model.

sweet maria's was fast, efficient, and had the order at my front door within a few days.  they are quick to respond to email inquiries, and couldn't be easier or nicer to deal with.  one of the better consumer experiences i have ever had!  i will be back to them for all my green beans.

Previous Review Next Review
Write a Review for this Product
review rating: 7.6
Posted: April 28, 2006, 10:39am
feedback: (0) comments | read | write
Login Password
forgot pw | signup
Commercial Equipment
Nuova Simonelli, La Marzocco, Rancilio. Nationwide installation. Instant financing options.
Cafe Solutions
Commercial sales and service, nationwide installation, equipment leasing options.
Home | Opinions | Consumer Reviews | Guides & How Tos | CoffeeGeek Reviews | Resources | Forums | Contact Us
CoffeeGeek.com, CoffeeGeek, and Coffee Geek, along with all associated content & images are copyright ©2000-2015 by Mark Prince, all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated. Content, code, and images may not be reused without permission. Usage of this website signifies agreement with our Terms and Conditions. (0.189383983612)
Privacy Policy | Copyright Info | Terms and Conditions | CoffeeGeek Advertisers | RSS | Find us on Google+